
Is there a more beloved American dessert than apple pie? People, especially in Vermont take it seriously. So much so that in 1999, Vermont passed a law about how it’s served. The law states, when serving a slice, a “good faith effort” must be made to serve it alongside a glass of cold milk, a large scoop of vanilla ice cream, or a slice of cheddar cheese. They go on to amend that the cheddar must weigh a minimum of ½ ounce. This law isn’t enforced, but it goes to show that in Vermont, apple pie and cheddar cheese is as classic of a combination as serving it a la mode.
Pairing cheese with pie, specifically with cheddar, began in the 17th-century in England. The British brought it over to our side of the pond. But is cheddar still the best cheese to serve with apple pie? At the Vermont Cheese Festival, we asked cheesemakers and experts which cheese they’d serve with a slice — and how they’d serve it. Most backed cheddar as the perfect pairing, but a few experts had other ideas.
